While we wait on our rebuild, check out these amazing pieces of Iconic Joey's Custard Merch!

On September 28, 2022 Hurricane Ian completed flooded and destroyed our beloved Joey's Custard. Our family is committed to re-opening this Iconic Sanibel Island shop as soon as Bailey's Center is rebuilt.

We miss yall so much and while we can't currently serve you our award winning desserts, we hope you might enjoy these cool pieces of Joey's Custard Island Merch in the meantime!

OFFICIAL Joey's Custard Merch...

View all

  • HOPE TO SEE YOU SOON!

    We miss you all! We are anxiously awaiting being able to serve all your smiling faces some of the best desserts on Sanibel! While our rebuilding and reopening details remain unknown for now we hold you all dear in our thoughts and prayers.

  • OUR MOTTO

    Aspire Nobly

    Encourage Harmony

    Serve Humbly

  • IT'S ALL IN THE FAMILY

    At Joey’s Custard, we like to say this is “Where OUR Family Serves YOUR Family”… and Joey’s has ALWAYS been a truly locally and family owned small business. The story of Joey’s ownership has been one of God-Sized proportion. We would love for you to stop by the store when we re-open so that we can tell you all about it!

    The Dellenback Family

  • Joey's Custard Reviews

    YELP named Joey's Custard as the

    #2 Ice Cream shop in Florida and

    #12 in the U.S.A.!!!

    Check out what our customers have said about us!

    Reviews